Different Color "Ink" for Same Product?

So, in the past, I’ve offered up the designs in my shop as black and white printing in men’s and women’s. Now, it appears there’s no way to duplicate an item (same shirt brand/style)? Is that correct? I’m not finding this new design tool all that intuitive. Am I missing something? It seems I can only add to my product selection with different products.

If you look at this page - it’s gotten really messy. Some of the shirts are all one color instead of the black and white options for both Men’s and Women’s. Like if you scroll down to the Platte River shirts, it looks like I’m offering 2 white graphics for Men’s. The design tool isn’t saving the “graphic color” choice.

Nevermind, I just added different products.

Indeed it’s not possible to set different design colors for the same design on the same product, so your solution is the way to go.